in

Families and DAs Move to Block Governor Gavin Newsom’s Mass Commute

Governor Gavin Newsom’s late‑term move to commute every death sentence in California has touched off a predictable legal and political firestorm. This week, the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation joined victims’ families, county prosecutors and law‑enforcement groups and asked the California Supreme Court to block or void the blanket commutations. The petition calls the governor’s action an unlawful power grab that cut victims and prosecutors out of a process the law guarantees.

What the new lawsuit claims

The petition filed in the California Supreme Court argues Newsom did not follow the notice and hearing rules that protect victims’ rights. It says the governor issued a categorical commutation without individual review and without giving victims or district attorneys a proper chance to be heard. Anne Marie Schubert of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation says the suit is about “protecting the constitutional rights of victims” and stopping a governor from acting like he is above the law. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman called the commutation “arbitrary” and said it sidelines juries, judges and voters.

Why this legal fight matters

The stakes are huge and immediate. Newsom’s list covers roughly 548 condemned people. About 380–400 of those involve defendants with multiple felony convictions, a group for which the state constitution requires the California Supreme Court’s recommendation before a commutation can take effect. That legal wrinkle is why plaintiffs went straight to the state’s high court, which now has docket filings and amici briefs on both sides. If the Court declines to act, those death sentences would likely convert to life without parole; if the Court grants emergency relief, the commutations could be paused or undone pending review.

Political theater dressed up as mercy

This is not just a dry legal fight. It’s raw politics. Newsom rolled out a blanket clemency plan on his way out the door — a move his supporters call corrective justice and his opponents call a thumb in the eye to victims and the rule of law. Whether you believe in the death penalty or not, the core complaint here is procedural: victims and prosecutors say they were denied the process the law promises. It’s hard to see that as anything but sloppy governing, at best, and a grandstanding end‑of‑term maneuver, at worst. Call it compassion by press release.

What to watch next

The big question now is what the California Supreme Court will do. The court can issue an emergency stay, set an expedited briefing schedule, or move to recommend clemency in the subset of cases that require its sign‑off. Keep an eye on whether Attorney General Rob Bonta files a position and how many district attorneys formally back the petition. Whatever the Court decides, this case will test the boundary between executive clemency and the procedural rights of victims — and it will tell Californians whether rule‑by‑reprieve can replace rule‑by‑law.

Written by Staff Reports

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Texas AG Paxton Quietly Pauses CAIR Terror Case Without Prejudice

Texas AG Paxton Quietly Pauses CAIR Terror Case Without Prejudice

Viral Purkiss Clip Puts Medicare for All and Taxpayers on the Hook

Viral Purkiss Clip Puts Medicare for All and Taxpayers on the Hook