Florida’s top lawyer, Attorney General James Uthmeier, dropped a legal bomb: his office says the state’s ban on bump stocks is unconstitutional under the Second Amendment and will no longer defend convictions under that law on appeal. That’s the big, new move—an advisory opinion that changes how the state will fight these cases, even if the law itself stubbornly stays on the books.
What the Attorney General actually did
The AG applied the Supreme Court’s Bruen test, which says modern gun rules must line up with America’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. He also leaned on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Garland v. Cargill, which said a semiautomatic rifle with a bump stock is not a “machine gun” under federal law. So Uthmeier says Florida’s 2018 law—Section 790.222—overreaches and criminalizes lawful uses of trigger enhancements. His office posted the opinion and plainly stated it will not defend convictions under that statute on appeal.
Why this matters — and why you shouldn’t confuse opinion with repeal
Let’s be clear: an AG opinion is powerful but advisory. The ban is still written in state law, and past convictions are not erased by this memo. County and state prosecutors can still bring charges if they choose. What the opinion does do is remove the state’s main lawyer from fighting appeals, which makes it much more likely courts will strike down the law if defendants press the issue. Governor Ron DeSantis praised the opinion, saying the state has been restoring Second Amendment rights and the AG is “leading once again.”
What to watch next — litigation, prosecutors, and lawmakers
Expect defense lawyers to use this opinion in court right away. Look for test cases asking judges to declare the statute unconstitutional. Keep an eye on local prosecutors to see whether they keep filing charges or quietly back off. Lawmakers can also act: a repeal bill (HB 6021) failed in a House subcommittee earlier this year, but this opinion will give fresh reason to revive repeal or revision efforts. In short, this opinion is the start of a fight that could force a court ruling or a legislative fix.
Bottom line
The AG’s opinion is a bold, pro-Second Amendment step that shifts how the state will defend bump-stock convictions. It does not erase the law, but it makes that law much harder to keep in court. If you care about gun rights or common-sense lawmaking, watch the courthouse dockets and the next legislative moves. The debate over bump stocks is moving out of press releases and into real legal battles—and the state’s own lawyer just handed the pro-rights side a potent new tool.

