Big retailers promised American shoppers that capping debit interchange fees would mean cheaper groceries and lower bills. Now a new national ad campaign from the Electronic Payments Coalition (EPC) is calling that promise a lie. EPC says “corporate megastores” pocketed $235 billion in savings instead of cutting prices, and it wants Congress to remember that before it hands retailers more favors.
What the EPC campaign is saying
The EPC rolled out a “Mr. Megastore” ad and a nationwide push that blares one number: EPC says $235 billion went to big chains after the Durbin Amendment’s debit-fee caps. The campaign cites independent research showing most merchants didn’t lower prices after the caps, including a Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond merchant survey and a recent analysis from the Progressive Policy Institute that documents how market changes blunted consumer benefits. To be fair, the $235 billion headline is an EPC estimate and the group should be asked to publish the full math. Still, the basic charge is simple: voters were promised savings and didn’t get them.
Legal and policy context — and why it matters
This ad campaign lands at a sensitive moment. An appellate court recently backed a ruling that struck down part of the Fed’s rule implementing the Durbin Amendment, and Congress is again considering bill language that would force similar rules onto credit cards. The Credit Card Competition Act has sponsors in the Senate, and EPC warns lawmakers not to repeat the same experiment with credit cards. If Congress ignores the record and votes for more mandates, it will be ignoring the real-world evidence EPC and others point to.
Who really won — and who lost
According to EPC’s materials, about 150 large chains captured a massive share of the savings — roughly 42.7 percent — while millions of Main Street shops got almost nothing. The Progressive Policy Institute’s analysis backs the headline point that pass-through to consumers was weak, and the Richmond Fed’s merchant survey found most businesses didn’t cut prices. Translation: the megastores kept the gains, many small merchants saw little benefit, and families saw no meaningful price relief. That’s not just poor policy; it’s bad faith marketing to Congress.
Congress should demand answers — and then act rationally
Lawmakers should do three simple things: demand the EPC and anyone else making big claims show their math; ask the big retailers why they didn’t pass on the savings; and reject new mandates until we have clear proof consumers will benefit. Conservatives should not reflexively defend every corporate giant, especially when those giants come to Washington asking for more rules that will cage competition and reward scale over fairness. If the $235 billion number is too neat to trust without the ledger, then get the ledger. But don’t hand over another regulatory blank check because a trade group promises it will be different this time.
The EPC ad is a welcome reminder that promises made in front of Congress are supposed to be kept. If lawmakers want to protect families and small businesses, they’ll demand transparency, hold megastores to account, and steer clear of one-size-fits-all card mandates that have a long record of disappointing results.

