Pennsylvania is staring at a plain and simple choice: will Governor Josh Shapiro sign the state up for the federal Education Freedom Tax Credit, or will he punt and let families miss a real chance to expand school choice? Senator David McCormick sent a blunt letter urging the governor to opt in now, warning that “the window of opportunity for Pennsylvania is rapidly closing.” That warning couldn’t be clearer — the state must file its advance election by the Jan. 1, 2027 deadline if it wants this program to help families next year.
What the Education Freedom Tax Credit actually does
The Education Freedom Tax Credit, or EFTC, creates a federal income tax credit for donations to Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs). Individuals can get up to $1,700 off their federal tax bill for qualified gifts; married couples file jointly for a bigger cap. SGOs then use those donations to give need-based scholarships for tuition, tutoring, classroom supplies and other education services. Pennsylvania already has the EITC and OSTC programs — the state has the paperwork and nonprofit networks to make this work quickly if the governor chooses to act.
Why McCormick is pushing now — and he’s right about the deadline
McCormick’s point is practical, not theoretical. The federal rules require an advance election to participate by Jan. 1, 2027 and a list of qualifying SGOs to the IRS by mid-February 2027. That’s not a suggestion; it’s a filing schedule. The Treasury said states can rely on proposed rules for contributions starting in 2027, so waiting for perfectly final regs is a luxury Pennsylvania can’t afford if it wants families to benefit next year. If you care about giving more options to parents and kids, “we’re still reviewing it” is not much of an answer when the calendar is ticking.
Politics, opponents, and the usual hand-wringing
Of course there will be noise from the teachers’ unions and their political allies. They’ll say this takes money away from public schools and opens the door to vouchers. That’s the standard playbook. But several Democratic governors have already opted in because the donations are private funds routed to scholarship groups, not a direct hit on state general funds. Meanwhile, Republican lawmakers and school-choice groups are pushing hard for action here — and McCormick’s letter adds federal pressure the governor can’t ignore without looking like he chose politics over kids.
What Governor Shapiro should do next
Governor Shapiro can be “open” to school choice all he likes, but openness doesn’t help a single child unless it turns into a filing. The governor should direct his agencies to make the advance election, publish the list of eligible SGOs, and let the EITC/OSTC network do the heavy lifting. If he still has legal questions, fine—file to opt in and keep litigating the fine print later. Opting in now keeps Pennsylvania’s options open; failing to act shuts the door for a year.
Here’s the bottom line: Senator McCormick is doing what any responsible lawmaker should do — prod action when a deadline matters. If Governor Shapiro truly wants to expand opportunity for Pennsylvania families, the path is clear and the work is already mostly in place. Opt in, don’t stall — and let parents decide what’s best for their kids instead of letting politics decide for them.

